Despite the progress made in championing women’s rights, there is still a stigma surrounding breastfeeding that persists. An intriguing incident arose when a woman had to make a difficult decision to emergency breastfeed her best friend’s baby, only to have her friend stop speaking to her as a result. This incident begs the question: is it acceptable for a woman to breastfeed another woman’s child? Last year, a Reddit user faced confusion and scrutiny after emergency breastfeeding her best friend’s two-month-old baby. Due to her friend’s struggles with postpartum depression and disconnection from motherhood, the user stepped in to help care for the baby for the day. However, a mishap led to a situation where the baby needed to be fed and the proper formula was not provided. As a last resort, the user chose to emergency breastfeed the child to ensure his well-being. Upon her friend’s return, instead of understanding and gratitude, the response was a harsh one, leading to a breakdown in their relationship. Seeking insight and validation, the user turned to the Reddit community for advice. Most commenters rallied in support of the user, emphasizing the importance of a child’s welfare above all else. They encouraged her to seek help from Child Protection Services for the friend and her baby’s well-being. Furthermore, the incident shed light on the stigma and pressure that surrounds breastfeeding. Mothers are often judged based on their choices regarding breastfeeding, facing social and personal insecurities. Despite the discomfort some may feel, the act of breastfeeding another woman’s child is not as unusual as perceived, with historical precedents such as wet nursing dating back centuries. While it may be uncommon in modern Western society, it still exists in many cultures worldwide. Stringent precautions, such as health screenings and considering the age match between children involved, must be taken before engaging in wet nursing. Despite the complications, the act of breastfeeding someone else’s child is rooted in historical norms and continues to be a practice in various cultures.